'Outrageous' price tag: Plant Vogtle cost doubles to $28.5 billion as other owners balk
ATLANTA — The cost of two nuclear reactors being built in Georgia is now $28.5 billion, more than twice the original price tag, and the other owners of Plant Vogtle argue Georgia Power Co. has triggered an agreement requiring Georgia Power to shoulder a larger share of the financial burden.
Atlanta-based Southern Co. announced in its quarterly earnings statement Thursday that Georgia Power's share of the third and fourth nuclear reactors at Plant Vogtle has risen to a total of $12.7 billion, an increase of $264 million. Along with what cooperatives and municipal utilities project, the total cost of Vogtle has now more than doubled the original projection of $14 billion.
Related:Georgia Power allowed to bill customers $2.1B for Plant Vogtle expansion
More coverage:How the developments at Plant Vogtle affect you
Opponents have long warned that overruns would be sky-high. Liz Coyle, executive director of consumer advocacy group Georgia Watch, said the price tag is “outrageous” but also predictable.
“We said you can't build it for what you're saying you can,” she said of Georgia Watch's opposition to the project when the Georgia Public Service Commission originally authorized the new reactors.
Total costs are actually higher than $28.5 billion, because that doesn’t count the $3.68 billion that contractor Westinghouse paid back to owners after going bankrupt. When approved in 2012, the first electricity was supposed to be generated in 2016.
The company and regulators insist the first new U.S. reactors in decades are the best source of clean and reliable energy for Georgia. Opponents say other options would be cheaper and better, including natural gas or solar generation.
Southern Co. also disclosed Thursday that the other owners of Vogtle are saying Georgia Power has tripped an agreement to pay a larger share of the ongoing overruns, a cost the company estimates at up to $350 million. Southern Co. said it disagrees that Georgia Power has crossed the cost threshold but has signed an agreement to extend talks with the other owners on the issue.
Georgia Power owns 45.7% of the new reactors, while cooperative-owned Oglethorpe Power Corp. owns 30%. The Municipal Electric Authority of Georgia owns 22.7% and the city of Dalton's municipal utility owns 1.6%. Florida's Jacksonville Electric Authority is obligated to cover some of MEAG's costs. Some cooperatives and municipal utilities in Alabama and northwest Florida have agreed to buy power as well.
The higher costs stem from more construction delays. Georgia Power announced last month that it doesn't expect Unit 3 to start generating electricity until the third quarter of 2022. It was the third delay announced since May. Unit 4 is now projected to enter service sometime between April and June of 2023.
Previous reporting:Georgia Power pushes back Plant Vogtle start date, second time in three months
Issues include missed deadlines and an 'unrealistic schedule'
The company says it is redoing substandard construction work and contractors aren't meeting deadlines. Experts hired by the Georgia Public Service Commission to monitor construction have long said Southern Co. has set an unrealistic schedule. In August, the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission found two sets of electrical cables meant to provide redundancy in Unit 3 weren’t properly separated. Earlier, Georgia Power had to repair a leak in Unit 3′s spent fuel pool.
Georgia Power shareholders have been paying the cost of recent overruns, but the company could ask regulators to require customers to pay some or all of those bills.
Other owners almost walked away in 2018, only agreeing to keep going after Georgia Power agreed to protect them from some additional overruns.
The Thursday stock filing indicates that the other owners now believe that the cost threshold has been reached requiring Georgia Power to pay a larger share of the project. Beyond a certain point, Georgia Power is required to pay 55.7% of costs, up from its 44.7% ownership stake. After another $800 million in overruns, Georgia Power would be required to pay 65.7% of the next $500 million. Above that price, other owners can sell parts of their ownership shares back to Georgia Power.
Southern Co. told investors that Georgia Power disagrees that it has reached the threshold, but said the owners had signed an agreement Oct. 29 to “clarify” how the 2018 deal will work.
It wasn't immediately clear Thursday exactly what is being negotiated or when an agreement might be reached. Oglethorpe, MEAG and Georgia Power didn't immediately respond to emails and phone calls seeking comment.
The Georgia Public Service Commission plans to vote this month on what could be a $224 million rate increase to pay for $2.1 billion in construction costs on Unit 3.
Georgia Power’s 2.6 million customers have already paid more than $3.5 billion in Vogtle borrowing costs. Customers of Oglethorpe-served cooperatives have already paid almost $400 million, according to financial statements.
